Franchise disputes: choose a clear route to resolution
Decide how disagreements will be handled before becoming a franchisor. A clear dispute resolution process protects both the working relationship and each business’s finances.
Published

When turning your existing business into a franchise, you also need to plan for situations where the relationship comes under strain. A disagreement over support, payment or the interpretation of the agreement can otherwise become both costly and drawn out. Franchising brings independent businesses together, and clear rules for handling disputes help preserve that relationship. Start, therefore, with the route to a solution, rather than simply deciding who is right.
1. Establish a process for disagreements before the first agreement
Within your own business, many issues can be settled by an internal decision. As a franchisor, however, you deal with an independent contracting party with its own financial interests. You cannot assume that the same decision-making processes will work when someone else owns and operates the outlet.
First, distinguish between routine operational issues and an actual contractual dispute. A problem with an ordering system can be handled by the support team. An allegation that the franchisor is failing to provide the agreed support, on the other hand, needs to be handled by someone authorised to represent the business.
Draw up a simple procedure setting out:
- how a party should describe the problem and its desired outcome in writing,
- who at each business receives the matter,
- when the recipient should respond and a meeting should take place,
- how agreements and any outstanding disagreements are recorded.
Make the procedure mutual. The franchisee should have just as clear a route for raising shortcomings on the franchisor’s part as the franchisor has for reporting a breach of contract. Also avoid giving the person whose conduct is being questioned sole responsibility for deciding how the complaint is handled.
2. Choose a dispute resolution forum based on costs and needs
Sweden has no comprehensive legislation specifically governing franchising. The Swedish Contracts Act and other general rules are therefore important to franchise agreements. Disputes can be heard in the ordinary courts or, where the parties have an applicable arbitration agreement, through arbitration. Arbitration in Sweden is governed by the Swedish Arbitration Act (1999:116).
The choice should be carefully considered, rather than copied as a matter of routine from another business’s agreement.
Ordinary courts: The parties do not normally have to pay the judges themselves, but legal representation can be expensive. The general rule in ordinary civil proceedings is that the losing party reimburses the other party’s reasonable litigation costs. Special costs rules apply to certain lower-value disputes. Documents and hearings are generally public, although some information may be subject to confidentiality.
Arbitration: The parties normally also pay the arbitrators’ fees and any institutional fees. Proceedings are not public in the same way as a court case, but do not assume that all participants are automatically bound by comprehensive confidentiality obligations. An arbitral award cannot normally be appealed on its merits, although it can be challenged on certain limited grounds.
Ask a lawyer to assess how these options would work for the disputes that could realistically arise within your franchise model. A small payment dispute and a major conflict over the right to use the franchise concept may call for different approaches. If different forums are to be used, the dividing line between them must be clear.
3. Include negotiation without blocking necessary action
An agreed negotiation procedure can give the parties an opportunity to resolve the problem before costs escalate. It might, for example, begin with a meeting between designated contacts and then escalate to the businesses’ senior management. Mediation involving a neutral third party can be another option.
Mediation helps the parties reach an agreement. The mediator does not determine the dispute in the way that a court or arbitral tribunal does. You should therefore decide how the mediator will be appointed, how the costs will be shared and when the attempt will end if no solution is reached.
Avoid a negotiation procedure that can remain open indefinitely. Also ask your lawyer to ensure that it does not prevent urgent protective measures or cause important deadlines to be missed.
Decide how the ongoing relationship will be managed during the disagreement. The starting point should be continued performance of the agreement, taking account of the applicable rights and obligations. The dispute resolution procedure should not give either party an ill-defined right to withhold support, supplies or payments as a means of exerting pressure.
4. Explain the dispute provisions before signing
Sweden’s Act on the Duty of Franchisors to Provide Information (2006:484) requires franchisors to provide clear, comprehensible written information in good time before the franchise agreement is entered into. This must include information on how disputes arising from the agreement will be resolved and who will be responsible for the costs.
It is therefore not enough to treat dispute resolution as an obscure standard clause. Explain the chosen procedure clearly in the pre-contractual information and ensure that the description matches the agreement. Avoid promises that a particular procedure will always be quick, inexpensive or confidential.
Finally, check that schedules and other agreements between the same parties do not create competing routes for resolving the same dispute. Have a lawyer review the arrangements as a whole and give the prospective franchisee the opportunity to seek independent advice.
Practical takeaway: Test the dispute resolution process against a hypothetical conflict before the first agreement is signed. Both parties should be able to understand whom to contact, how the matter progresses and what cost risks the proceedings involve.



