Autotaalglas: goodwill waiver upheld after 33-year franchise relationship
A former Autotaalglas franchisee has been denied €157,431 in goodwill compensation. The court held him to the terms agreed on his departure.
Published

A former Autotaalglas franchisee cannot claim goodwill compensation after 33 years of working together when he expressly waived that entitlement on his departure. The Zeeland-West-Brabant District Court dismissed his claim on 4 November 2026. For those operating in or considering the Dutch franchise market, the case highlights the importance of the terms agreed when a franchise relationship ends.
From retirement plans to a termination dispute
The businessman had operated an Autotaalglas outlet since 1992. In 2025, he wanted to retire. He had found a successor franchisee willing to take over his business. The franchise agreement provided for goodwill compensation if the relationship ended in the ordinary way.
His departure did not, however, follow that route. Autotaalglas terminated the franchise agreement early for breaches by the franchisee. In subsequent interim proceedings, the judge found that the termination was likely to be legally valid. This left the parties in a different position from the retirement originally envisaged.
Following that ruling, the parties entered into a settlement agreement. It provided for the business to be transferred to a successor franchisee. They also agreed that the departing businessman would waive any entitlement to goodwill compensation. That provision later became central to the dispute.
Ludwig & Van Dam Franchiseadvocaten discussed the ruling in a commentary published on 16 November. The judgment reference is ECLI:NL:RBZWB:2026:10962.
€157,431 claim fails because of agreed terms
Several months after signing the settlement agreement, the former franchisee nevertheless claimed €157,431 in goodwill compensation. He argued that Autotaalglas had taken unfair advantage of the circumstances in which he had signed the agreement. In his view, he had effectively had no choice but to agree.
The court rejected that argument. It took into account that both parties were experienced business operators and had received specialist advice. The court also found that the franchisee had other options. For example, he could have appealed against the interim ruling.
There was insufficient evidence of improper pressure. The businessman therefore remained bound by his agreement to waive goodwill compensation. His subsequent assertion that he had signed under considerable pressure was not enough, in this case, to set that agreement aside.
The ruling therefore did not turn solely on the length of the relationship or the existence of a goodwill provision in the original contract. The court also considered the circumstances in which the later settlement agreement had been concluded and the alternatives available to the businessman at the time.
Ordinary termination is not the same as termination for breach
The franchisee also argued that Autotaalglas had breached its contractual obligations and duty of care. That argument was unsuccessful too. The contractual goodwill provision applied to an ordinary termination, not to termination for breach.
This distinction is an important part of the case. Although the parties had agreed a goodwill provision, the court found that it did not provide a basis for payment where the agreement ended in this way. In addition, the parties had subsequently stated expressly in the settlement agreement that the businessman waived goodwill compensation.
The ruling illustrates why it is important to examine not just whether a goodwill clause exists, but also the circumstances to which it applies. Business owners preparing to leave a franchise should avoid treating a planned transfer and any dispute over termination as separate matters. In this case, both were addressed in a single agreement.
No general ruling on statutory goodwill rights
Ludwig & Van Dam’s commentary also identifies an important limitation: the judgment does not discuss Article 7:920(1) of the Dutch Civil Code, which contains the statutory franchise goodwill provisions. The ruling should therefore not be read as a general finding that goodwill rights lapse whenever a franchisee is forced to leave.
The specific combination of circumstances was decisive here: early termination for breach, the earlier interim ruling and a subsequent settlement agreement containing an express goodwill waiver. The parties’ experience, their specialist advice and the alternatives available also informed the court’s rejection of the argument that Autotaalglas had taken unfair advantage of the circumstances.
Practical takeaway: before signing an exit agreement, seek advice on which goodwill provisions apply, which forms of termination they cover and which rights you are waiving. Do not assume that a long-standing relationship will be enough to overturn an agreed waiver later.
Sources
- Audax zoekt herstel, Bruna en ReadShop open | Franchise+
- Franchise in cijfers: wat heeft de Wet franchise veranderd in de rechtspraak? - Ludwig & van Dam Advocaten
- d-reizen Archieven
- Goodwill na 33 jaar franchise: afstand in vaststellingsovereenkomst houdt stand - Ludwig & van Dam Advocaten
- Horizon-franchise is goed voor meer dan 38 miljoen verkochte exemplaren
- Kinderopvang franchise: kdv, bso of gastouderbureau?
- Waarom franchising vooral werkt voor ondernemers die zichzelf goed kennen



