Licence or Franchise? Assessing Your Business Model in Malaysia
A contract’s title does not determine whether an arrangement is a franchise. Review the rights, controls and payments before offering your business expansion model.
Published

Business owners looking to expand sometimes choose terms such as “brand licence”, “business partner” or “distributor” because they assume these are simpler alternatives to franchising. However, the label on a contract does not, on its own, determine its legal status. Before recruiting independent operators, examine how the relationship actually works. This helps you enter Malaysia’s franchise market with the right structure, rather than building a network that later needs substantial changes.
1. Understand that substance takes precedence over labels
Malaysia has specific legislation: the Franchise Act 1998 [Act 590], as amended, including by the Franchise (Amendment) Act 2020. Section 4 defines a franchise. That definition covers contracts or agreements that are express or implied, whether oral or written.
Calling a document a “licensing agreement” therefore does not, in itself, exclude the relationship from the Act. Equally, the absence of a written contract is not a safe basis for assuming that an arrangement is not a franchise.
Key elements to assess together include the grant of rights to operate a business under a system determined by the party granting those rights, the use of trade marks or related intellectual property, the right to exercise continuing control over operations, and payments or other forms of consideration. The recipient’s status as a separate business operator is also relevant.
This is not a simple test that can be settled by a single characteristic. A licence to use a trade mark alone is not necessarily a franchise. Conversely, a combination of brand rights, an operating system and continuing control may require closer assessment. Ask a lawyer familiar with Malaysian franchise law to review the arrangement as a whole.
2. Map the actual rights, controls and payments
Map out the business relationship before preparing your expansion package. Use the following four sets of questions to gather facts, not as a substitute for legal advice.
Rights granted: Is the operator simply buying products for resale, or acquiring the right to run a business under your brand identity? List the permitted uses of your name, logo, recipes, shop design, software and confidential know-how.
Mandatory systems: Do you prescribe how the business must be run as a whole? Record requirements relating to menus or services, workflows, customer experience, premises layout and management methods.
Continuing control: Do you have the right to require operational changes, check compliance, request reports or take action when standards are not met? Distinguish optional recommendations from binding instructions.
Payments and consideration: List all flows of money between the parties, including initial fees, system-use fees, product purchases and other charges. Do not assume that the absence of a payment called a “royalty” settles the classification question. The true nature of each payment needs to be examined.
Support each answer with evidence: draft contracts, sales materials, operating instructions, sample invoices or system screenshots. Also record who can change those terms. An assessment grounded in actual practice will be more useful than one based on the founder’s general description.
3. Compare contractual promises with operational practice
Imagine a food business offering a “brand licence”. The licensee uses the same name, must follow the owner’s menu and manual, submits sales reports, undergoes inspections and pays a system-use fee. This warrants assessment as a potential franchise arrangement, even if the contract is labelled a licence.
By contrast, a distributor buying goods for resale under its own shop identity may have a different relationship. However, do not draw conclusions solely from these examples; the full set of rights and obligations still needs to be examined.
Review the relationship across three levels:
- Documents: What rights and powers does the contract specify?
- Communications: What is promised in presentations, messages and sales conversations?
- Implementation: What instructions does the operator actually receive each day?
If the contract promises operational independence but your team controls almost every decision, flag that inconsistency for review. Do not simply delete certain terms to make the document look like a licence. The chosen model must reflect the actual relationship and the need to protect the brand.
4. Resolve the classification before making offers
Arrange a legal assessment before your sales team distributes offers to prospective operators. Give your adviser the relationship map, draft documents and examples of operating practices. Ask for a written explanation of the basis for the classification and the steps required.
If the model is a franchise, section 6 of the Franchise Act 1998 requires the franchisor to register the franchise before operating a franchise business or offering it for sale in Malaysia. Requirements relating to agreements and disclosure must also be met. Among these, section 15 requires the relevant documents to be provided to a prospective franchisee at least ten days before the agreement is signed.
If the model is not a franchise, that does not mean the relationship falls outside the law. The Contracts Act 1950 remains relevant to contractual relationships, while trade mark use must take account of the Trademarks Act 2019. Other obligations depend on the business’s actual activities.
Practical action: Before recruiting business partners, complete a map of the rights, controls and payments, then obtain legal confirmation of the model’s classification. Establish the structure first; name and market the package afterwards.
Sources
- Panduan dan sumber francais Malaysia | QFA
- Microsoft Word - Panduan Pendaftaran
- Memulakan Perniagaan Francais di Malaysia
- Panduan Pendaftaran Francais di Malaysia - Scribd
- www.franchise.org
- Setting Up A Franchise Business In Malaysia
- Malaysia Franchise & Licensing Contributor Wong Jin Nee & Teo
- Soalan Lazim



