Setting Out Dispute Resolution in a Franchise Agreement
Establish a clear dispute resolution process so that disagreements with franchise partners do not immediately disrupt outlet operations.
Published

Before franchising a business, owners need to decide how disagreements with franchise partners will be handled. Differences over invoice calculations, the interpretation of standards or the provision of support can develop into disputes if the resolution process is unclear. In franchising, a dispute resolution clause is not a sign of mistrust. It provides a shared framework for keeping the process orderly, balanced and workable.
1. Establish the legal basis and scope of disputes
The main legislation governing franchising in Indonesia is Government Regulation No. 35 of 2024 on Franchising, which replaced Government Regulation No. 42 of 2007. It stipulates that a franchise relationship must be based on an agreement between parties of equal legal standing and governed by Indonesian law. Dispute resolution is one of the matters that must be covered in the franchise agreement.
This means you should not simply copy a sentence stating that “disputes shall be resolved through consultation”. That wording does not explain who will negotiate, when the process begins or what happens if no agreement is reached.
Define the clause’s scope clearly, for example by covering disputes over the interpretation of the agreement, the performance of obligations, payment calculations and alleged breaches. Ask a legal adviser to ensure that this scope is consistent with the chosen resolution process.
Also distinguish contractual disputes from regulatory compliance matters. An agreement between a franchisor and franchisee does not override licensing or reporting obligations, or the powers of the relevant authorities. A single issue may require both a contractual resolution and separate compliance action.
2. Set out workable negotiation stages
Start with a written notice of dispute. This document should set out the issue, the provisions of the agreement in question, the sequence of events, supporting evidence and the remedy sought. The aim is not to create more paperwork, but to ensure that both parties are discussing the same problem.
Specify the following in the agreement:
- Official postal and email addresses for notices.
- How to determine when a notice is deemed to have been received.
- Deadlines for responding and the duration of negotiations.
- Representatives of each party with authority to make decisions.
- How to record an agreement or the failure of negotiations.
These time limits are contractual choices that need to be agreed, not standard periods that can be assumed to apply to every franchise. State clearly whether they are measured in calendar days or working days.
Keep the handling of day-to-day operational complaints separate from dispute negotiations. The support team may be able to explain the facts, but may not have authority to agree to a reduction in charges or a change in obligations. Involve decision-makers before the negotiation period expires.
If the parties choose out-of-court mediation, explain how the mediator will be appointed, how costs will be shared and how long the process may take. A mediator helps the parties reach an agreement; they are not a judge deciding who wins. If a settlement is reached, document the obligations, deadlines for implementation and those responsible for carrying them out.
3. Choose a final forum without conflicting clauses
If negotiations or mediation fail, the agreement must provide a next step. Two common options are court proceedings and arbitration. Do not list both as final forums that either party can freely choose without explaining how they relate to one another and the limits of their jurisdiction.
Arbitration is governed by Law No. 30 of 1999 on Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution. This route requires a written arbitration agreement and can only be used for disputes that may legally be resolved through arbitration. An arbitration agreement has implications for the jurisdiction of Indonesia’s district courts to hear disputes covered by it.
If you choose arbitration, ensure that the institution’s name, procedural rules, place of arbitration, language and mechanism for appointing arbitrators are unambiguous. Consider the costs and both parties’ ability to participate in the process, particularly where the amount in dispute is relatively small.
If you choose court proceedings, ask a legal adviser to check the wording of the court selection clause and its compatibility with jurisdictional rules. Do not assume that naming a court automatically resolves every jurisdictional issue.
The choice of forum should be discussed before signing. Prospective franchise partners need to understand its consequences, rather than discovering them only when they receive a notice of dispute.
4. Specify which activities must continue during a dispute
A disagreement over one invoice does not necessarily mean that the entire business relationship must stop. Identify the obligations that must continue during the process, where legally permitted and appropriate to the circumstances. These might include maintaining customer safety, protecting confidential information and paying undisputed amounts.
However, do not draft a business continuity clause that forces an outlet to carry out unsafe or unlawful activities. Separate the need for urgent action from the resolution of the underlying dispute, then ask a legal adviser to ensure that these provisions are consistent with the chosen forum.
Put evidence management procedures in place too. Keep versions of the agreement, formal notices, transaction records, meeting minutes and correspondence in an orderly manner. Restrict access according to responsibilities; do not use a group chat for all franchise partners to debate an individual dispute.
Before offering a franchise, test the clause with a scenario: a franchise partner refuses to pay part of an invoice because promised support has not been provided. Work through who receives the notice, who negotiates, what evidence is needed and where the dispute goes next.
Practical takeaway: establish a written process from the initial notice through to the final forum. A good clause ensures that both parties know the next step without having another disagreement about how to resolve the dispute.
Sources
- Ubah Bisnis Jadi Penghasil Royalti: Panduan Urus Legalitas Bisnis ...
- PP No. 35 Tahun 2024 tentang Waralaba | Peta Hukum
- bahwa dalam yang - JDIH BPK RI
- [PDF] PENGATURAN WARALABA DI INDONESIA - OJS ITB-AD
- Begini Cara Memulai Bisnis yang Legal di Indonesia, Simak!
- Berita waralaba Hari Ini - Kabar Terbaru Terkini
- 1195
- PENGATURAN HUKUM TENTANG FRANCHISE DI INDONESIA



