How Businesses in China Can Design a Tiered Dispute Resolution Process Before Franchising
A franchise agreement needs more than a promise to resolve disputes through discussion. Before recruiting franchisees, franchisors should establish a clear route from receiving complaints and organising evidence to mediation, arbitration or litigation, reducing the impact of disagreements on outlet operations and trust across the franchise network.
Published

Turning an existing business into a franchise network requires more than proving that its outlets can be replicated. It also means answering some questions in advance: if the franchisor and a franchisee disagree over service delivery, fee settlement or responsibility, who will handle the dispute, on what basis, and what happens if talks fail? A workable dispute resolution process should be in place before the first agreement is signed, rather than hastily assembled when a solicitor’s letter arrives.
1. Make dispute resolution a contractual process, not a statement of goodwill
China has specific regulations governing commercial franchising. Article 11 of the Regulations on the Administration of Commercial Franchising requires the parties to enter into a written franchise agreement and lists liability for breach and dispute resolution methods among its principal provisions. Simply stating that ‘the parties will resolve matters through amicable discussions’ therefore does not provide a clear, workable arrangement.
Consider a three-tier process: fact-finding by the relevant operational manager, negotiations led by an authorised decision-maker, and escalation to the agreed formal dispute resolution procedure. For each tier, specify how disputes are submitted, which role is responsible, the handling timeframe and the conditions for escalation. Internal handling deadlines are agreed between the parties; they should not be presented as uniform statutory requirements.
The clause should also make clear that internal negotiations do not prevent either party from lawfully applying for interim protective measures or taking other necessary legal steps, and must not cause them to miss statutory deadlines. Requiring franchisees to ‘complete all of the franchisor’s internal appeal procedures’ should not become an indefinite barrier to seeking legal remedies.
2. Establish independent intake and a standard evidence checklist
Disputes often reach a franchise recruitment manager or field support manager first, but someone directly involved in the matter should not decide the outcome alone. For example, if a franchisee complains that the franchisor has failed to provide agreed support, allowing the person responsible for that support to decide alone whether the obligation was fulfilled can deepen mistrust.
The franchisor can appoint a dispute coordinator to log cases, route them to the appropriate people and monitor deadlines, with a manager who was not directly involved reviewing the matter. A small team may not need a separate department, but it should identify an alternate responsible person and specify when external legal advisers should be brought in.
For each case, compile the following materials in a consistent format:
- Agreement and schedules: identify the specific clauses in dispute and the applicable versions.
- Performance records: retain service tickets, deliverables, payment records and correspondence or notices.
- Each party’s position: record their factual accounts, requested remedies, calculations and supporting grounds separately.
- Timeline: distinguish between agreed facts, disputed facts and outstanding evidence.
Keep original documents and their full context, rather than selecting only chat excerpts that favour one side. Access to the materials should also be restricted: a franchisee’s business information should not be forwarded to unrelated group chats. The purpose of a dispute file is to establish the facts, not to create a tool for public pressure.
3. Give negotiations clear authority, deadlines and written outcomes
Once a dispute has been received, first clarify what is disputed and what remedy is being sought, then arrange discussions involving people with the authority to act. Before the meeting, establish who can explain performance records and who can approve additional services, fee adjustments or a settlement. This avoids frontline staff repeatedly making promises they cannot fulfil.
A tabletop exercise with the company-owned outlet management team can help test the process. Assume that support promised by the franchisor was not delivered on time, and ask operational, finance and management leads to simulate the investigation and negotiations. Check whether they can locate complete records, identify responsibility and propose a workable solution. This is not a statutory requirement, but a way to test whether the process works in practice.
Any negotiated agreement should be recorded in writing, specifying the obligations to be performed, amounts payable or calculation methods, completion dates, acceptance criteria and what happens if the agreement is not fulfilled. Where rights are waived or liability is released, define the scope clearly. A blanket statement that ‘the parties have no further disputes’ is no substitute for specific terms.
For undisputed obligations that can still be performed normally, the parties may separately confirm arrangements for continued performance. The franchisor should not treat suspending supplies or system access as default negotiating tactics. Before taking such steps, it should check the contractual basis, legal risks and potential impact on consumers.
4. Define the formal resolution route clearly and keep it consistent
The agreement should clearly select an appropriate route through arbitration or litigation. If arbitration is chosen, accurately specify the arbitral institution and the scope of disputes covered, and have the arbitration agreement reviewed by a professional familiar with Chinese law. If litigation is chosen, any jurisdiction clause must comply with legal requirements. Avoid loosely stating that disputes ‘may be arbitrated or brought before any court’, which can create a dispute over the procedure itself.
The parties may also agree to try mediation before formal proceedings, but should explain that participation is voluntary, how mediation is initiated and how the matter moves to the next stage if no agreement is reached. Do not describe commercial negotiations as matters that a government regulator is necessarily obliged to accept or adjudicate.
The Regulations on the Administration of Commercial Franchising also require franchisors to provide the prescribed information and the agreement text in writing at least 30 days before entering into the agreement. Dispute resolution clauses should be included in the proposed text so that prospective franchisees can understand the procedures and costs in advance, rather than encountering new provisions at the signing table. The final agreement, schedules and internal handling guidelines should also be checked for consistency. Internal guidelines cannot unilaterally curtail contractual rights.
Practical takeaway: Before recruiting your first franchisees, prepare a dispute resolution clause, a case registration form and an evidence checklist, then run a simulated dispute through the entire process. A genuine capacity to handle disagreements means being able to identify the person responsible, establish the facts and move promptly towards an effective resolution.



