Before Franchising in China: How to Tell Whether a Brand Licensing Arrangement Is a Franchise
Calling a contract ‘brand licensing’ or ‘business cooperation’ does not put it outside China’s franchising rules. Before recruiting partners, businesses should assess the substance of the arrangement, focusing on business resources, a uniform operating model and fees.
Published

Businesses with existing outlets often seek to expand their networks through ‘brand-licensed stores’, ‘partner stores’ or ‘city partners’. These labels do not determine the legal nature of the arrangement. Before entering the franchise market in China, a business should review the parties’ actual rights and obligations. If the arrangement amounts to commercial franchising, it should prepare to comply with the relevant rules rather than wait until contracts have been signed and then change the terminology.
1. Assess the substance using three elements
Article 3 of China’s Regulations on the Administration of Commercial Franchises defines commercial franchising as an arrangement in which an enterprise with business resources, such as registered trade marks, corporate logos, patents or proprietary technology, contractually licenses those resources to another operator. The franchisee operates under a uniform business model as agreed in the contract and pays franchise fees to the franchisor.
Businesses can use this definition to draw up an assessment table, recording the actual arrangements and supporting evidence for each element.
- Are business resources being licensed? Look beyond trade marks to licences covering store signage, proprietary recipes, service procedures or other business resources. The absence of formal trade mark licensing procedures does not, by itself, mean that no resources are being licensed.
- Must the partner follow a uniform operating model? Check whether the partner must comply with head office requirements for store appearance, product range, operating procedures and service standards. Basic product quality requirements are not the same as providing a complete operating model; the scope of control needs to be considered.
- Are franchise fees being paid? Do not look only for charges labelled ‘franchise fees’. Examine management, system and training fees, as well as the actual purpose of other payments and what is provided in return.
This is not a mechanical box-ticking exercise. The three elements should be assessed in the context of the entire transaction. The presence of branding or training alone does not automatically determine the outcome.
2. Review all documents and actual practices together
A single commercial relationship may involve separate trade mark licensing, purchasing, software services and consultancy agreements. If those agreements collectively provide for brand licensing, uniform operations and fee payments, reviewing just one in isolation will not be sufficient.
The business lead should gather partner recruitment materials, quotations, contract schedules, store-opening checklists, operating requirements and payment arrangements for a consolidated legal review. The key question is not how many documents there are, but what they collectively require the partner to do.
Prepare a ‘rights–control–fees’ table, with each row recording:
- The rights granted by head office and the scope within which the partner may exercise them;
- The operating practices prescribed by head office and whether the partner has discretion over them;
- The payments the partner makes in return and who receives them;
- The document supporting each arrangement and whether actual practice matches it.
For example, a contract may describe the partner as a ‘distributor’ while requiring it to use a standard store name, follow a comprehensive operations manual, receive ongoing operational guidance and pay management fees. Such an arrangement warrants close assessment to determine whether it constitutes franchising. Conversely, buying branded goods and reselling them independently does not amount to franchising merely because the goods bear a trade mark.
Payments collected separately by affiliated companies, additional oral requirements and separate service agreements should all form part of the same review. They should not be treated as unrelated matters outside the contract.
3. Examine arrangements that are easily misclassified
‘No franchise fee’ does not necessarily mean the fee element is absent. If the business earns most of its revenue from supplying goods, check whether payments relate solely to those goods or also include consideration for business resources and support for uniform operations. An ordinary supply margin should neither automatically be treated as a franchise fee nor automatically excluded. Pricing, contracts and actual performance all need to be considered.
‘Trade mark licensing only’ should be consistent with the degree of operational control. If the business also provides systems for product selection, preparation or production, service delivery and store management, assess whether the relationship goes beyond merely licensing a mark. Equally, the quality supervision requirements inherent in trade mark licensing should not automatically be equated with a uniform operating model.
‘Joint investment’ requires a review of the underlying relationship. Equity participation does not automatically place every store arrangement outside franchising rules. Identify the actual operator, the party using the business resources and the party bearing the fees, then consider whether a separate franchise relationship also exists.
For borderline proposals, ask legal advisers to produce a written opinion setting out the basis for their assessment, any facts still to be confirmed and any clauses that need amendment. The conclusion should go beyond ‘yes’ or ‘no’ and explain which changes to the business would trigger a reassessment.
4. Make the assessment a prerequisite for partner recruitment
Once an arrangement is confirmed as franchising, preparations should follow the Regulations on the Administration of Commercial Franchises. The franchisor must be an enterprise with a mature operating model and the capacity to provide ongoing guidance, technical support and training. It must also meet the requirement to have at least two directly operated outlets that have been operating for more than one year.
The business should also prepare a written franchise agreement, provide the legally required disclosures and contract text at least 30 days before the agreement is concluded, and apply for filing within 15 days of concluding its first franchise agreement. Filing is not an administrative licence obtained before starting to franchise, nor does it replace verification that the eligibility requirements have been met.
If the business does not yet meet the requirements, it cannot continue with the same arrangement simply by calling it ‘joint operation’ or deleting the words ‘franchise fee’. It should pause recruitment for the relevant partnerships, meet the outstanding requirements, or genuinely restructure the business arrangement following professional review. Both the documents and actual performance must change accordingly.
If the arrangement is assessed as straightforward trade mark licensing or goods distribution, it must still comply with applicable legislation, including the Civil Code of the People’s Republic of China and the Trade Mark Law of the People’s Republic of China. The original conclusion should be revisited whenever uniform store management, additional licences to use business resources or new charges are introduced.
Practical takeaway: Before recruiting partners, bring all agreements, operating requirements and payment flows together in a single table for review. The nature of the relationship depends on the actual arrangements, not the title on the contract cover.



