Franchise Supply Disruptions: Checking Alternative Sourcing and Liability for Losses Before You Sign
When essential ingredients fail to arrive on time, both sales and customer trust suffer. Before signing, check delivery standards, alternative purchasing procedures and who bears the costs of supply disruptions.
Published

However good a brand’s products are, a shop cannot operate normally if essential ingredients fail to arrive on time. The more a franchisee depends on a designated supply chain, the more important it is to assess the risks of delivery delays and stock shortages before starting the business. To keep the franchise network running reliably, the franchisor and franchisees need to agree in advance how they will handle supply problems. Before signing, look beyond assurances that a logistics network exists: obtain written details of supply standards and commitments for dealing with disruptions.
1. Check the actual supply terms, from ordering to receipt
Start by asking the franchisor for its logistics operations manual, ordering schedule and delivery charges. Even if the agreement simply states that goods will be supplied, order cut-off times, available delivery days and minimum order quantities will affect how much stock and cash you need to keep on hand. Check that the terms explained by the franchise representative also apply to your proposed premises.
Delivery frequency is not the only consideration. Distinguish between scheduled and emergency deliveries, and check how orders are handled around weekends and public holidays. Ask whether special conditions apply to islands or locations far from distribution centres. Also record whether the franchisor handles transport itself or uses an external logistics company.
- When are orders received and confirmed, and can quantities be reduced after confirmation?
- Are there extra delivery charges or dispatch restrictions for orders below the minimum quantity?
- Who checks deliveries with missing items, and by when must those items be supplied?
- If the first delivery is delayed just before opening, who should you contact and how?
The definition of a completed delivery also matters. Leaving goods outside the premises is not the same as having the franchisee check their quantity and condition. If unattended deliveries are allowed, it is sensible to agree separately on storage locations, maintenance of chilled or frozen conditions, and procedures for investigating loss or damage.
List delivery-related expenditure separately from the cost of goods in your start-up budget. Repeated small-order surcharges, emergency transport charges and storage costs can make operations more expensive than the initial estimate suggests. If charges have not been fixed, first establish how they will be calculated and how changes will be notified.
2. Agree in writing whether alternative purchasing is allowed during shortages
Franchise transactions in South Korea are governed by the Fair Transactions in Franchise Business Act. Article 6 sets out franchisees’ obligations, including maintaining appropriate stock levels and product displays, and complying with appropriate quality standards set by the franchisor. You should therefore avoid substituting ingredients indiscriminately simply because supplies are delayed.
This does not mean that franchisees must tolerate supply interruptions indefinitely. Before signing, agree on alternative purchasing procedures that allow you to continue trading while meeting quality standards. Distinguish between statutory obligations and the emergency arrangements that the parties need to negotiate.
For example, ask whether you may buy an essential ingredient from another approved supplier if it is out of stock, or temporarily use a product with the same specifications. What matters is not just whether this is permitted, but who grants approval and how quickly they must respond. It should also be clear whether you must suspend sales while waiting for a decision.
Obtain the requirements for approving substitutes in advance. Knowing which details the franchisor needs to check—such as product specifications, country of origin, ingredients and storage conditions—can save time in an emergency. It is safer to agree that approval will be recorded by email or through the ordering system, rather than relying solely on a telephone conversation.
Any price difference and additional delivery charges arising from alternative purchases are separate issues. Do not assume that approval from the franchisor means it will also cover the costs. Check who pays in which circumstances, and whether prior approval and receipts are required. If no alternative supply is possible, you will also need procedures for notifying customers of suspended sales and resuming them.
3. Distinguish responsibility for delivery incidents from supply interruptions
Treating every logistics problem as the same type of incident can leave responsibility unclear. An order overlooked by the franchisor, a misdelivery by a logistics company, a manufacturer halting production and transport disruption caused by a natural disaster have different causes and call for different responses. Check whether the agreement distinguishes between these situations, and ask for someone to be designated to establish the cause.
In particular, if a clause says that the franchisor is not responsible for problems involving the logistics company, examine the underlying supply contract arrangements. The issues to review will depend on whom you pay for the goods and who has promised to supply them. Using an external delivery company does not automatically remove the franchisor’s responsibility.
Article 6 of South Korea’s Act on the Regulation of Terms and Conditions provides that unfair standard terms which breach the principle of good faith are void. Terms that are unreasonably disadvantageous to the customer, among others, are presumed to be unfair. However, the validity of a particular exclusion of liability depends on its wording and the circumstances of the transaction. Do not assume a clause is void simply because it appears unfavourable.
Review losses by category as well. Adjusting payments for undelivered goods, replacing defective products, covering additional emergency purchasing costs, paying disposal costs and compensating for losses caused by suspended sales are separate matters. A procedure for refunding the price of goods does not automatically entitle you to compensation for reduced sales.
Ask for the agreement to specify how incidents must be reported, what evidence is needed—such as photographs or temperature records—and the arrangements for collection, replacement and financial settlement. Whether damages are payable, and to what extent, may depend on the contract, responsibility for the incident, causation and evidence. Broad exclusions of liability are best reviewed by a legal adviser before you sign.
4. Prepare a response plan before opening by testing disruption scenarios
Finally, work through possible supply disruptions with the franchisor. Separately consider an essential ingredient arriving a day late, repeated short deliveries and a supplier being unable to dispatch goods for an extended period. These scenarios can reveal gaps in vague assurances. Start by establishing the first action the franchisee should take in each case.
Your response plan should record the type of problem, the contact person, the alternative purchasing approval procedure, who bears the costs and what supporting evidence is required. If you must contact a separate logistics company, check whether you must notify the franchisor at the same time. You will also need contact arrangements for when the person responsible is on leave or a problem occurs outside normal working hours.
Holding more stock will not solve every problem. Limited shelf life and storage space can increase waste and stock management costs. Calculate the buffer stock needed for each item based on its rate of use and delivery cycle, and check whether the quantities required by the franchisor are compatible with your premises’ storage capacity.
The answers should be reflected consistently in the agreement and its supporting documents. If the operations manual permits alternative purchasing but the agreement prohibits all external purchases, clarify which provision takes precedence and resolve the inconsistency. Ensure documents show their date and the premises to which they apply, and retain the final agreed versions.
Action summary: Before signing, obtain both a delivery standards schedule and a supply disruption response plan. If it is unclear who will restore supplies, approve alternative purchases and pay additional costs, clarify those terms before deciding whether to join the franchise.



