Franchising in Argentina: how to review contractual penalties
Before buying a franchise, check which breaches trigger penalties, how they are calculated and what procedure allows you to challenge them.
Published

A contractual penalty can turn a correctable operational mistake into a substantial financial liability. Before buying a franchise, knowing the regular fees is not enough: you need to understand which actions are penalised and how you can respond. In franchising, protecting brand standards and setting clear consequences are compatible with a fair procedure.
1. Identify which obligations carry a penalty
In Argentina, franchise agreements are specifically regulated by Articles 1512 to 1524 of the national Civil and Commercial Code. Penalty clauses also fall under the general rules in Article 790 onwards of the same Code. There is no single statutory schedule of penalties for all franchises.
A penalty clause sets a penalty for delay or failure to fulfil an obligation. Your review should therefore start with the conduct that triggers it, rather than the amount.
Ask for the full draft agreement and any schedules that set out sanctions. Look for terms such as “penalty”, “breach charge”, “daily penalty” or “penalty clause”. The label alone does not determine its legal nature.
Prepare a list with three columns: obligation, breach and consequence. For example, distinguish between submitting a report late, failing to submit it altogether and providing false information. If the wording applies the same response to very different situations, ask for an explanation and more precise wording.
Watch out for broad phrases such as “any failure to comply with standards”. You should be able to identify exactly what conduct is required, where it is documented and when it becomes binding.
2. Calculate your exposure, not just the initial penalty
An apparently manageable amount can multiply if it is charged per day, per outlet or for each incident identified. Before agreeing, work through the calculation using written examples.
Pay particular attention to:
- Basis and currency: whether the penalty is fixed or depends on sales, franchise fees or another reference figure.
- Frequency: whether it is charged once or continues to accrue while the breach persists.
- Start and end points: when it begins to accrue and what stops it accumulating.
- Cap: whether there is a maximum per incident or per period.
- Multiple penalties: whether a single incident can trigger several penalties.
If the penalty is linked to sales, clarify which period is used and how the calculation works if the outlet has not yet opened or has been closed. If it increases for repeat breaches, ask for a definition of what counts as a repeat and how long previous breaches remain relevant.
Also ask how the penalty interacts with interest, damages and other contractual consequences. The general rules on penalty clauses address their relationship with damages and performance of the obligation; individual provisions should not be read in isolation.
Have a lawyer review the provisions as a whole. The aim is to understand your actual exposure, rather than assume that every amount mentioned can automatically be charged on top of the others.
3. Negotiate a procedure for remedying breaches and responding
Financial clarity is no substitute for a procedure. Before signing, propose that the agreement specify who gives notice of a breach, how they do so and what supporting documentation they must provide.
For breaches that can be remedied, negotiate a requirement for formal notice describing the problem and allowing a reasonable period to put it right. Do not treat that period as an automatic right applying in every situation: it needs to be assessed in light of the obligation and the relevant rules.
A useful procedure should clarify:
- What evidence supports the alleged breach.
- How you can submit explanations or documentation.
- Who verifies that the remedial action was sufficient.
- What happens to the penalty while its application is disputed.
- How the closure of the matter is recorded.
Distinguish administrative errors from incidents requiring an urgent response, such as a safety risk. Nor should you assume that remedying the conduct necessarily cancels a penalty that has already accrued: that relationship must be expressly clarified.
4. Review the limits before committing
Article 794 of the Civil and Commercial Code allows judges to reduce penalties where, under the conditions it sets out, their disproportionate amount constitutes abusive exploitation of the debtor’s situation. This does not mean that every high penalty is invalid or that you can reduce it unilaterally.
Relying on a court dispute is not a sound purchasing strategy. It is better to negotiate verifiable obligations, transparent calculations and proportionate consequences now.
Keep the final version of the agreement and its schedules. If an issue is raised later, document the dates, communications and corrective measures. Do not assume that an informal conversation overrides a formal written notice.
Practical takeaway: before signing, make sure you can answer four questions: what triggers the penalty, how much can accumulate, how the breach can be remedied and how the penalty can be challenged. If any answer remains unclear, negotiate more precise wording with legal advice.
Sources
- Comprar una franquicia: cómo evaluar el local y su alquiler
- Desarrollo de la red de franquicias | Buenos Aires Ciudad
- Crear una franquicia - Gobierno de la Ciudad de Buenos Aires
- Guías y recursos sobre franquicias en Argentina | QFA
- Cómo comercializar la franquicia
- Argentina - Distribution and Sales Channels
- EL MARCO LEGAL DE LAS FRANQUICIAS: KNOW-HOW, CRECIMIENTO Y ESTRATEGIA CONTRACTUAL. Herramientas para el Asesoramiento y la Estructuración del Negocio
- Conocé el paso a paso de cómo exportar franquicias



